In April, a master plan that consultants prepared for the City of Independence proposed selling the Vaile Mansion and the Bingham-Waggoner Estate to private buyers. KCUR reported that the PGAV Planners proposal suggested a token price of $1 because of the properties' condition. Seven months later, on Nov. 3, voters approved General Obligation Bond Question No. 1. It authorizes up to $19.9 million to repair both mansions and three more city-owned sites: the Truman Memorial Building, Old Fire Station No. 1 and the 1827 Log Courthouse. FOX4 counted 24,164 yes votes to 11,060 no, or 68.6%.
If Independence is on your list because of its history, that vote settles something you would otherwise have had to guess at. For most of 2026, the futures of the city's two best-known historic houses as public places were undecided. Now both stay with the city, they have money set aside for repairs, and the city has a 20-year business plan for their care.
A Spring When Selling Was on the Table
The April plan sorted nine city-owned historic sites into three groups, according to KCTV's April 13 report. The Vaile Mansion and Bingham-Waggoner would be sold to private buyers, with improvements estimated at $12 million to $15 million or more. Five properties, including Historic Fire Station No. 1 and the Truman Depot, would go to a conservancy to own or manage. The National Frontier Trails Museum and the Merrill J. Mattes Research Library would stay with the city.
That plan followed a 2025 ballot in which Independence voters turned down a $12 million historic-sites bond by what The Beacon called a narrow margin. The Kansas City Star reported that City Manager Troy Anderson said in April the city was spending more than $125,000 a year to operate its historic sites, and that objections to the sale idea came at a public meeting and on social media.
Brent Schondelmeyer of the Save our Historic Sites campaign told KCUR the sale suggestion is what got residents moving. "The suggestion to sell motivated people to say, 'Let's go get this issue on the ballot and give the community an opportunity to provide a reasonable funding source to secure their maintenance and upkeep for future generations,'" he said. Mayor Kevin King made the city's position plain at an Aug. 17 council meeting, as The Beacon quoted him: "Historical sites are extremely important to the city, and they need to stay with the city."
What Each Building Gets
The repair list shows what condition these buildings are in. The figures below are the pre-election scopes and allocations. Now that the bond has passed, the city says it will refine the scopes and set priorities.
- Bingham-Waggoner Estate, more than $6.6 million per KSHB. The plan covers chimney repointing and capping, porch baluster, railing and column repairs, and new exterior trim ahead of repainting.
- Vaile Mansion, nearly $4 million per KSHB, for replacing rotted wood, masonry repointing, exterior painting and minor roof maintenance.
- Truman Memorial Building, $1,012,620, for interior drywall and paint, new cast-stone surrounds, exterior repainting and roof repairs.
- Old Fire Station No. 1, $985,180, for facade and masonry repairs and restoring its south-side windows.
- 1827 Log Courthouse, $749,910, for replacing deteriorated logs, rebuilding the front porch and columns, a new shingle roof and window and door restoration.
Nearly all of that is exterior work on chimneys, porches, trim, masonry, roofs and windows, most of it visible from the street.
Some of the damage already shows. KCTV reported that a failing exterior lintel at Old Fire Station No. 1 led to barricades. Severe weather in early September damaged the facade further, and the building closed to the public. That firehouse holds the National Park Service visitor center for the Truman Historic Site, and the Independence 76 Fire Company operates from its basement. At Bingham-Waggoner, KCTV reported that the slate roof and six chimneys are deteriorating, interior plaster is falling and a kitchen floor is unstable, and that summer heat above 100 degrees cost the estate nearly two months of tours.
Who Looks After What
The work falls mostly to the city, because these are exterior repairs. The Bingham-Waggoner Historical Society operates the estate under a contract with the city. The society maintains the artifacts inside, and the city maintains the 19-acre park and all the outbuildings, according to KCTV's April report. The same report says more than 95 percent of what's inside the house is original to the Waggoner family, who lived there for over 100 years before the city bought it. At the Vaile Mansion, the Vaile Victorian Society has a city contract to maintain the interior, and the city is responsible for exterior repairs. The city has held both houses for decades. It partnered with the historical society to acquire Bingham-Waggoner in 1979 and accepted ownership of the Vaile Mansion in 1983.
The bond also pays for a 20-year business plan to guide future capital improvements and maintenance. The city says it will use that plan to evaluate how its historic properties are maintained and to avoid another significant backlog of repairs. "Now it's our responsibility to make the most of this investment, not only by addressing the needs of these buildings today, but by planning for how we will care for them over the next 20 years and beyond," Anderson said in the city's post-election announcement.
What It Means if You Live Here
Before the election, KCUR reported that all five sites would offer free admission to city residents until the bonds are retired. The city put the cost at about $30.65 a year for a home at Independence's average value of $173,000, a figure based on 2024 Census numbers, in its historic sites FAQ. With free admission, the Vaile Mansion, Bingham-Waggoner and the Log Courthouse can be ordinary Saturday stops, not only places for out-of-town relatives.
Turnout at the houses was already strong. KCTV reported that more than 750 people visited the Vaile Mansion and the Bingham-Waggoner Estate during free Sunday tours in the final weeks before the vote. Former Mayor Eileen Weir told KCUR that citizen satisfaction surveys over the years show history ranks high with voters. "Without fail people, want to preserve Independence history," she said.
The next step belongs to the city. It says it will refine each site's scope, set priorities, go through procurement and share timelines as plans develop. Until then, the repair list above is the best guide to which facades will have contractors on them. The Truman Memorial Building continues as the city's community and recreation center, with an auditorium, a gym, fitness classes and event rentals.
For more on how Independence's historic core is changing, read our look at the new all-day diner at 208 Main on the Square, or start with our Independence neighborhood page.
Picture the Vaile Mansion or the Truman sites as part of your weekend walk? Blake & Associates can show you Independence homes within an easy walk of these five landmarks and talk through what that location is worth. If you already own near them, start with a free home valuation.